“How old were you then?” I ask, wanting to know every single detail.

“I was twelve by the time they got married. I haven’t seen Tim since that last day in court, but Steve made up for it tenfold. I remember the day of the wedding telling my new stepbrother, Jared, how lucky he was and I wished Steve was my real father. Later on that night, when Steve asked me to dance, he told me that he loved me like his own, and if I wanted, he’d be more than thrilled to have me take the Dawson name. After bursting into tears and asking him about ten times if he really meant it, I said yes. That was the second happiest day of my life. Tim didn’t fight it for a second, and within six months, I was Lucy Dawson, with a new father, brother, and a baby sister on the way. It was the first time in my life that I really felt like I was part of a family.”

She turns in my arms as she wraps one of hers around my back. “Here’s the thing though. I’d spent ten years hearing how I wasn’t wanted, wasn’t needed, and I felt like I was worthless when it came to love. No matter how much Mom and Steve showed me affection, one man’s emotional torment was too strong to break hold. My sophomore year of high school, I was at a party after a football game. I’d been drinking a little, and a guy I was seeing at the time pulled me into an empty bedroom. Long story short, one thing led to another, and I ended up losing my virginity on the floor of a dirty bedroom. The worst part was the whole school knew about it by Monday morning and my brand-new nickname was plastered on my locker.”

I look down into her eyes, unable to read her expression. She’s speaking as if it’s just another ordinary thing when all I want to do is find that asshole and beat the shit out of him for not only ruining her first time, but for being a prick and spreading the news.

“Nickname? Do I even want to know?”

She lets out a small laugh. “It’s not that bad. There I was, sixteen and I’d had sex once in my life. Before that, I’d only ever messed around with one other person, but for the kids of Gulf Breeze High, that’s all it took. Their less-than-original Loosie Lou was all over my locker for the whole school to see.”

“Kids are fucking brutal. Baby, that was fucked up. You know that, right?” She places a finger on my lips then points to her belly. I give her a sheepish look, having forgotten myself for the moment. “Maybe for talks like these, we should put headphones on your belly so he can drown out the sound of his parents’ conversations.”

“I’ll remember that next time, Kale. But as for the nickname, it wasn’t all that bad. In some weird, twisted way, I liked the reputation. As guys started saying they’d hooked up with me, too, I took it as a sign that I was wanted. Messed up, right? For someone who spent her first decade being reminded that she wasn’t wanted, it made me feel good inside to know that so many guys thought I was special enough that they just had to claim that they’d had me, too.” She shakes her head and lets out a small laugh. “I know that sounds so stupid now, but at the time, the logic made sense to me. Looking back on it, I know it wasn’t that they wanted me. They just wanted to say that they’d also had a chance to bag the school whore, when in reality, I didn’t have sex again until I was in college.”

I honestly have no idea how to respond, and she gives me a reprieve by continuing. “You know about Noah,” she says, and I remember the conversation we had about her college boyfriend. “There wasn’t anything painful there, no terrible breakup, and by the time we split up, I was in a really good place. And for the first time in my life, I took control with how I dealt with relationships. Which ultimately led me to you. Meeting you, Kale Montgomery, was the third happiest day of my life. I might not have known it at the time, but my life changed significantly that day, and if I’d had any idea the impact you’d have on me, I probably would’ve run screaming from the classroom. Instead, I was practically giddy when I saw you waiting for me in that parking lot. And then that night? Well, you were there. Let’s just say I was more than happy to accept your friends-with-benefits proposal.” She smiles up at me—the sweetest smile she’s ever given me.

“What I thought would be a summer of fun turned into almost four of the best months of my life, followed by the worst nine as I watched you date that guy from seven thousand plus miles away.”

Her smile turns earnest, almost rueful. “The day you left for Afghanistan, I was devastated, and that’s when I knew you were so much more than my best friend. At the time, I realized I couldn’t do casual anymore, because you’d basically ruined me for all others. What I didn’t know was that you didn’t just ruin me for casual flings, but for any other man. I’m not proud of it, but I tried to forget my feelings for you while I was dating him, yet in the end, they’d only grown stronger.”

“We’re kind of a sad pair, right? All that time wasted because we didn’t want to admit that we had feelings for each other. Until him,” I tell her, rubbing my hand over her belly.

“Maybe not sad… Stubborn, perhaps? Oh well. It doesn’t matter now. When I found out about Sprout, that became the new happiest day of my life, but it was also one of the scariest. And I hope that telling you about Tim can kind of help you understand why I was so hesitant to jump into a relationship at first. I was terrified that the only reason you were expressing feelings for me was because of him. At the same time, I realize how hypocritical that was, because I didn’t tell you how I felt until then either. And I know how unfair it was to project what my father did onto you, but I couldn’t help it. It felt like the past repeating itself, and it scared the sh–er, crap out of me. Which is why I shut you out. I don’t know if I’ve ever said it, but I am really sorry for that. You were so sweet, so gentle and reassuring, and all I could do was kick you out of my apartment and ignore you for the next two days. It’s a wonder you even put up with me.”

Leaning in, I press a kiss against her forehead before looking directly into her eyes. “I put up with you because I love you. Because I want to spend the rest of my life with you. You’ll drive me nuts, I’ll make you pull your hair out, but at the end of the day, it’s you and me, and I wouldn’t change that for the world.”

“You mean you and me and baby,” she teases, lightening the tone of the night.

“True, but it was you and me first, and you’ll always be first for me, Lucy. I appreciate you telling me all that. It does kind of put things into perspective for why you were so resistant in the beginning.”

“I know, and I should’ve been honest and open about it from the beginning, but it was just hard, you know? We’d been whatever the hell we were for so long that the thought of opening up and changing everything was too frightening to even think about. I guess we have this little guy to thank for pushing us to finally be truthful with one another.”

“I know I’ll be thanking him for the rest of my life,” I tell her. “Now, come on. It’s been a long damn day, and I want to get to the hospital first thing in the morning to see how Lily’s doing.”

I watch as her eyes soften, and she brings a hand up to caress my face. “She’s going to be okay, Kale. Like she said, the worst was that they shaved her hair. If that’s not a sign that she’s thinking clearly, then I don’t know what is.” Lucy lets out a small laugh, but I can’t bring myself to find any humor in the situation. I know she’s just trying to keep things light, but I can’t help the overwhelming sense of guilt that seeps back in.

“When she’s home without a bandage on her head and with healed ribs, I might believe you,” I tell her, and she sighs softly.

“Kale, you cannot blame yourself for this. Even Xavier knows it was an accident. You’re just going to be miserable if you keep beating yourself up. That won’t do you any good, and it won’t do Lily any good. You saw her, babe. She was fine. She was laughing and chatting, and she was more than happy to see you.”

I know she’s right, but she wasn’t there. She doesn’t have the images and the sounds replaying over and over in her mind. “I can’t stop seeing her, Lucy. I should’ve been able to stop her, but she was just too damn fast. I was supposed to protect her. She’s my goddaughter for crying out loud, and I couldn’t even keep her safe. What the hell kind of father am I going to be?”

“Oh, Kale,” she whispers as she moves in closer so her belly’s pressed up against my abs. She grabs my hand, brings it down to rest on her stomach, and looks deep into my eyes. “Every single day, you show me what an amazing father you’re going to be. From the moment I met you, I’ve known that. And when you saw Lily tonight, you should’ve seen that, too. She didn’t feel a single ounce of blame towards you, and at the end of the day, there was nothing you could’ve done.”

She leans up and gives me a slow, lingering kiss on the lips before pulling back. “Whatever you’re thinking, Montgomery, you need to stop. I love you. Lily loves you, and Sprout’s going to love the hell out of you. Now get some sleep. We’ll go see her in the morning, okay?”

Nodding, I give her a small smile before she turns over, settling in with her back against my chest. “I love you, too, baby,” I tell her, and I mean it.

As we lie in silence, I replay her admissions over and over in my mind, and I wonder just how in the hell I’m going to get up the courage to finally tell her all about my past. Everything she said just scares me even more, because I don’t want her to feel like she’s a replacement—or that Sprout is—for everything I lost so long ago. But now that I know the history of her biological father, I’m terrified she’s going to find some sort of link between me and him, and I decide, probably foolishly, that her knowing about what happened all those years ago isn’t important. At least not for now. I know it’ll probably come back to bite me in the ass, but I’m taking the coward’s way out.